Does Paying Off Debt Automatically Help Pre-Approval?

While eliminating debt can certainly improve your financial outlook, it’s not always the golden ticket.

You want to buy a home, and you know mortgage pre-approval plays a big role in the process. Maybe you think paying off debt automatically helps with pre-approval. That makes sense, right? Less debt should make lenders more likely to approve you. 

Unfortunately, it's not always that simple. While reducing debt helps in many cases, other financial factors play a role. Before you drain your savings to clear balances, take a closer look at how lenders assess your mortgage application.

The Impact of Paying Off Debt on Your DTI Ratio

Your debt-to-income (DTI) is a ratio or percentage of your monthly income that goes toward bills and debt. To calculate it, add up all your monthly debt payments and divide that number by your gross monthly income (income before taxes). Lenders typically prefer a DTI below 43%, though some loan programs allow higher ratios. 

Here's an example to illustrate this clearly:

Gross Monthly Income: $6,000 (before taxes)

  • Total Monthly Debt: $1,000

    • Car payment: $500

    • Student loan: $200

    • Credit card minimum payment: $300

  • DTI Ratio: 16.7% ($1,000 ÷ $6,000)

In this example, the DTI ratio is 16.7%, which is really good because it’s well below the 43% threshold.

Now, if you pay off the credit card balance ($300), your total monthly debt decreases to $700. This means that your DTI ratio drops to 11.7% ($700 ÷ $6,000).

How Credit Score Affects Pre-Approval

Your credit score reflects your history of managing debt, and lenders use this number to determine your creditworthiness. Paying off debt can sometimes boost your score, but it depends on how you handle accounts.

Suppose you owe $2,500 on a credit card with a $5,000 limit. Your credit utilization ratio stands at 50%, which lenders don’t love. Paying down this balance to $500 lowers your utilization to 10%, which may improve your credit score significantly.

But here's where it gets tricky because closing a paid-off account can shorten your credit history and reduce your score. If your credit profile depends on that history, wiping out balances and shutting down accounts might backfire. Instead of closing paid-off credit cards, consider keeping them open with occasional small purchases to maintain a strong credit history.

Revolving Debt vs. Installment Debt

Lenders view revolving debt (credit cards) differently than installment debt (car loans and student loans). Credit card debt carries higher interest rates and fluctuates based on spending habits. This makes revolving debt way riskier in a lender’s eyes. Paying down credit card debt often helps your mortgage application because it lowers the amount of available credit you're using and improves your DTI ratio.

Installment loans have fixed payments and timelines, which makes them more predictable. Paying off a $15,000 auto loan with a $400 monthly payment lowers your DTI, but it may not make as much of a difference as reducing credit card debt. 

Plus, keeping an installment loan with a solid payment history could actually help your credit profile. If you’re choosing between paying off a car loan or hitting your credit card debt, the credit card balance usually takes priority.

When Paying Off Debt Hurts Pre-Approval Chances

Paying off debt can sometimes work against you. If you use cash reserves to pay down debt, you might not have the funds for a down payment, closing costs, or emergency expenses. Lenders assess your overall financial picture, not just your debt levels. They want to make sure you have enough savings and financial stability to comfortably handle the upfront costs and ongoing expenses associated with a loan. In other words, not having those extra expenses could negatively impact your mortgage pre-approval.

Another potential pitfall is paying off collections or charge-offs right before applying for a mortgage. It sounds like a responsible move, but in some cases, it may lower your credit score temporarily. Some lenders prefer you address outstanding debts before pre-approval, while others ignore old collections. Always consult a mortgage professional before making large debt payments to ensure the best strategy for your situation.

How Timing Affects Mortgage Pre-Approval

Lenders review your credit report when you apply for pre-approval. If you recently paid off a debt, the change doesn't automatically show up on your credit report. It usually takes several weeks (or perhaps even longer) for credit bureaus to update their information.

For example, if you pay off a credit card balance in June, you shouldn’t expect a credit check in July to already reflect the change. That’s frustrating, for sure, but it’s just the reality of how credit reporting works. If you want your best chance of automatically getting pre-approved, you should plan your credit clean-up strategy months in advance. 

Paying Off Debt Doesn’t Automatically Help Pre-Approval

So, does paying off debt automatically help pre-approval? Not always. While reducing debt lowers your DTI and can improve your credit score, lenders look at the bigger picture. Before making any drastic financial moves, assess your entire situation. A well-thought-out strategy—not just a zero balance—can make all the difference in securing that mortgage approval. But above all, consulting a mortgage professional can help you develop the best strategy for securing pre-approval.

—————————————————————————————————-

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Does paying off debt always improve my chances of mortgage pre-approval?

While paying off debt can lower your debt-to-income (DTI) ratio and possibly improve your credit score, it doesn't automatically guarantee mortgage pre-approval. Lenders evaluate your overall financial picture, including savings, credit history, and your ability to cover upfront costs like down payments and closing fees. Sometimes paying off debt might even hurt your chances if it leaves you short on savings for these costs.

2. How long does it take for my credit score to reflect debt payments?

It typically takes several weeks for your credit report to reflect any recent debt payments, as updates from credit bureaus don't happen instantly. If you're planning to pay off debt before applying for a mortgage, it’s best to do so months in advance, giving the credit bureaus enough time to update your report before your pre-approval application.

3. Should I prioritize paying off my credit card or car loan before applying for a mortgage?

Credit card debt should usually be your priority when paying off debt before applying for a mortgage. Credit cards carry higher interest rates and affect your DTI ratio more significantly than installment loans like car payments. Plus, reducing your credit card balance can boost your credit score, making you more attractive to lenders.

4. Can paying off collections or charge-offs hurt my credit score before applying for a mortgage?

Paying off collections or charge-offs might temporarily lower your credit score. Some mortgage lenders may view this as a red flag, as it could indicate financial instability. It’s always a good idea to consult a mortgage professional before paying off old collections to make sure it won’t hurt your pre-approval chances.

5. How much debt is too much when applying for mortgage pre-approval?

Lenders generally prefer your DTI ratio to be below 43%. If your DTI is higher than that, it could signal to lenders that you might struggle with monthly payments. However, some loan programs allow for a higher DTI. The key is balancing your debt with sufficient income and savings to demonstrate financial stability.